I've carried M9 but on a thigh rig, and g26 IWB as a civilian, but I have no experience with OWB full frame hip carry on a packed duty belt in civilian style vehicles. A place for discussion on law enforcement and criminal justice issues. Kinda leaning toward the CZ 75b at the moment. Other features. Does it make any discernible difference? And, what makes this even more interesting, the Glock 19 shares all of the same attributes of the Glock 17. Can we have the a "17 vs 19" list in the sidebar? The surefire is a hair longer than my 34. The olight and tlr are the same length. I daily carry a G19. Hot. Both these semi-automatic pistols use 9mm cartridges and were designed by Gaston Glock. Battlefield Green 17, my first piece. Polymer80 Glock 19 Bare Bones Kit – Threaded Stainless Steel Barrel – RMR Cut Slide Sale! € 444,44 (1) Glock 17 Gen. 4 Flat Dark Earth Sondermodell im Kaliber 9mm Luger € 789,00. Sight radius is 6.38-inches, empty weight is 25.56 ounces, and as mentioned before it’s chambered in 9x19mm. Maybe check out the S&W M&P9c. The slide also features a little more length at 6.26-inches. As to Glock 17 vs Glock 19 recoil, there isn't a great deal of difference. I appreciate the response. Price point: The Glock 17 is around $500-600 MSRP, whereas the VP9 is around $700-750. ... Facebook Twitter Reddit LinkedIn Pinterest Email. Gleiches Griffstück, gleiche Munition, 100% größerer Streukreis. Notify when back in stock. As the title states, I have to choose between Glock 17 and 19 as a new hire. I carry the 23 for duty but will be switching to the 22 soon. Personal preference, imo. If you searching to test Glcok 43 Vs Glock 19 And Glock 17 Vs Glock 19 Reddit price. You can’t go wrong with either, they’re both excellent choices for a range/home defense/duty gun. ... M&P9 2.0 C VS Glock 19. The two fifth-generation models announced were the Glock 17 and Glock 19, chambered for the 9x19 mm Parabellum. Is it just a shape and feel thing that suits you personally or is there something universally preferable? Hope you all enjoy this video! Which I think is worth the $50 price difference. That's what I'm hearing. It's a GREAT carry gun. If you get a G19x, enjoy and shoot it well. $ 396.97 $ 359.17 Read more. The Glock 19 has an overall width of 1.34" while the Glock 48 has a slim overall width of only 1.10". I was concerned with vehicle comfort but haven't heard any complaints about 17 so the difference must be negligible. The Glock 17 fits my hand better( than a Glock 19) and additionally is the same size as a 1911 commander size which have a loyal following of concealed carry users . whichever ones feels best to you. Get the 17 or the 34 if you're not planning to carry it and the 19 (not X) if you want it as a CCW. The Gen5 Glock 17 MOS. Notify when back in stock. It was my first ever pistol and I love it but its purpose is as a range and home defense gun, both of which tasks will likely go to my duty 17 for obvious reasons. Aside from the color, you get two extended mags and nights sights. Nun wir alle kennen das techn. The barrel on HK’s striker-fired sweetheart is 4.09-inches long, polygonal, has 6 grooves, and a right-hand twist. Top Searches Holiday Gifts. Both take 9mm cartridges, both are made from the same high-quality mix of steel and polymer, and both of them ar… Super glad I did. 4. I own both. Since it is a smaller gun, it is more popular for concealed-carry uses. The Load Out Room author Scott Witner’s Glock 17 loaded with Minuteman Munitions. RMR’d the 21. “Teh light extends past teh barrel becuz it seeves as a standoff to prevent going out of battery during contact shots! Follow-up question: are there any good reasons to keep a personal 17 once I'm issued a department one? It'll give a you a little more sight radius and 2 more rounds in the stock mags. 9mm kicks the least of the major defense calibers, but they all have some thump. 5 years ago. It's a good one because guys and gals are buying them up. u/sewage. If you wanted to, you can even find mags for the Glock that are well over the 17-round limit of the M&P, with 33-round, and 50-round drums available. The 19 does it all. It's really not. Also called ported barrel. Shop for Low Price Glock 17 Standard Trigger And Glock 17 Vs 19 Recoil Reddit .Compare Price and Options of Glock 17 Standard Trigger And Glock 17 Vs 19 Recoil 0 9 2 290. Reply. I know the difference is not great but over a long career the larger 17 frame could become irritating working in and out of patrol vehicles. For example, the subcompact Glock 26 will accept magazines from both the full-size Glock 17 and the compact Glock 19, but the Glock 17 will not accept magazines from the smaller Glock 19 or the Glock 26. mountainman13, Sep 1, 2012. mountainman13, Sep 1, 2012. Magazines. The 17/26 have the same spacing, but on the 19 the grooves are closer together which some people don't like. If they're the same, get the 17 (or better yet a 34). I would say I tend to shoot the Glock 19 better ironically, but I wanted to get a full size gun for the capacity and the full barrel length. The Glock 17 wasn't the first polymer-framed nor even striker-fired pistol; Hechler and Koch beat Glock to those punches more than a decade before Glock invented the 17. Hoping to keep it between $400 and $600. This means that it is classified as a compact, and not a full-sized pistol.Beyond this, the guns are actually very similar. So does the Surefire X300. Glock 17M vs Glock 17 Gen 5 So I haven't seen any mention of this yet, but can anyone say what the differences between the two are? There must be something otherwise … If you don’t carry a Roland Speshul you is gonna die!”. And you have a choice of Gray or Black. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. The GLOCK 19 is billed as being better for people with smaller hands, but only marginally so; the trigger reach (the distance from the back of the pistol grip to the front face of the trigger) is only 0.03 inches longer on the GLOCK 17 vs GLOCK 19. Posted by. The Glock 20 handgun has an overall length of 8.07 inches, compared to 8.04 inches for the original Glock 17. Sep 1, 2012 #3 . 4. luna 9mm Para Beiträge: 28 Registriert: Di 5. My 34 shot the "softest" but had the most muzzle rise. I'm not sure what the scientific explanation behind it is, but I've noticed the same with other pistols to. Rising. Re: Glock 17 vs Glock 34 Gen 4. The 19 is less than 1.5 ounces lighter, and the barrel is only about.5 inches shorter though the 4-inch barrel of the 19 is more than adequate to help tame any recoil. The insight apl would be the same length as a 17. While the links are now dead, Reddit user MadPuggle was able to snag a screenshot of the Glock 17 Gen 5 MOS. Dürfte also wurscht sein, kauf was dir gefällt. Beitrag von Lichtgestalt » Do 13. The surefire x300, streamlight tlr1-hl, and olight valkyrie ii all extend past a 17. I am not a big fan. You can’t go wrong with either, they’re both excellent choices for a range/home defense/duty gun. I actually prefer my 19X of my G17. log in sign up. Each gun has serious merits and both are among the most popular handguns on the market to date. More rounds is a good thing in my opinion. 17 all the way. The 17 was going to be to big for AIWB for me, and the 26 would not afford same grip angle achived after I did a grip reduction on the 19. The Glock 9mm “Family”: 17 (Full Size), 19 (Compact) , 26 (SubCompact). Could you explain why you prefer the 19? Posted by 10 hours ago. Related Posts Instructor Level Courses November 2019. Which looks dumb. Thousands of rounds through 3rd gen 17 and 4th gen 26 but never fired a 19. Metal night sights installed at the factory makes it my favorite 9mm Glock right off the bat. save. card. Die Glock 17 ist eine Selbstladepistole im Kaliber 9 × 19 mm, die von der österreichischen Glock GmbH hergestellt wird. The completed slides weigh less than the factory delivered slides. Glock 19X vs Glock 17. The Glock 17 has a compact sibling in the Glock 19 and a sub-compact sibling Glock 26. Not sure if I'll be getting gen5 as a new hire now that they're available and same cost to police, so I don't know if finger grooves will be an issue. “What is the difference between a Glock 17 and a Glock 19?” The Glock 17 was designed first, intended for use by the Austrian Army. Plus I really dig the finish. It's purely a placebo effect. The 17/26 fits like a glove. Carried 17 for years and years but switched to 19 last year. It's purely a placebo effect. Whatever you feel most comfortable shooting. My G19X is awesome. Glock 19 is effectively a reduced-size Glock 17; it is called the “Compact” by the manufacturer.The Glock 19 has a shorter barrel (by about half an inch) and pistol grip compared to the Glock 17. Posted by 18 hours ago. I considered the 17 and 26 before settling on a 19. (Also, the FDE is cool). It is considered the Compact Size Glock where the Glock 17 is considered the Full-Size Glock. Die beliebte Glock 17 Pistole im Waffen Online Shop bei Frankonia kaufen. Hot New Top Rising. A place for responsible gun owners and enthusiasts to talk about guns without the politics. I considered the 17 and 26 before settling on a 19. The Glock 17 did well in the American commercial market but many buyers clamored for a handgun with a shorter barrel and slightly shorter magazine, resulting in the Glock 19. These are Generation 3 or later with the “finger grips” and attachment rails. Most of this difference is due to the 48 being a slim double stack whereas the 19 … The stripped Orion slides with RMR cover plates are available for Glock 19 and Glock 17 Gen 5 models. gen5 Love it. If I want a 19, get a 19. Been mainly looking at the CZ 75b and a Glock 17 or 19. 329. As always, different strokes for different folks. Full size for duty use. 2 years ago. There's a slight difference in the grips between the 17 and 19. Has anyone shot both who could tell me any difference you’ve noticed? I have big hands. Both the Glock 17 and 19 are truly outstanding guns, making use of the latest materials and a design which is simple and reliable. A lot of people say that it’s a weird amalgamation of parts and should be flipped, having the 17 slide/barrel and the 19 frame, but I honestly really enjoy mine. Both of them offer the same triple-safe-action mechanism, both are best-selling handguns, and both boast deadly accuracy in the right hands. I have a Glock 17 and I shoot it fine with my medium sized hands. The Glock 17 semi-automatic 9mm caliber handgun, even with no accessories whatsoever, is still a great weapon that serves its purpose well. However, it wasn’t until Smith & Wesson released their M&P 2.0 compact that there was a direct competitor to the Glock 19. Okt 2011, 10:59 Auch wenn es Leben manchmal doch auf ein paar cm mehr ankommt liegen die beiden Glockmodelle haarscharf nebeneinander und unterscheiden sich nur geringfügig in der Größe und Mag-kapa. 9 9. comments. I will call in short word as Glock 17 Vs 19 Stripped Slide And Difference Between Ip Vpn And Internet Vpn For folks who are looking for Glock 17 Vs 19 Stripped Slide And Difference Between Ip Vpn And Internet Vpn review. Press J to jump to the feed. The 17 was revolutionary when unveiled in 1984. 1 5 1 151. The “Baby Glock” G26 will also take the Glock 19’s fifteen-round magazine, the Glock 17’s... 1 result. … Hdq said: Will a 15 round glock 19 magazine fit into a full size framed glock 17? However, Glock arguably makes the best, and it was the Glock 17 that started the poly striker craze. 1 Kevin Greene; 2 Saturn And Jupiter; 3 Christie Smythe; 4 John Mulaney; 5 Omaha Steaks Tv; 6 K T Oslin; 7 Small Suv Sale; 8 Movers Near Me; 9 Donald Trump; 10 Kilauea; Top Searches Holiday Gifts. None of my local ranges has a 19X to rent, and I’m trying to decide between the two for my next purchase. Press J to jump to the feed. The finger groove spacing on the front strap is different between the two guns. The advantage of reduced slide weight is that it helps reduce fatigue and should allow for faster follow-up shot placement. !Glock Pistol Spec. Trending. You’re giving up a bit of sight radius, velocity and weight ca a G17. Glock 17 vs. 19. If you're using the same magazines, go with whichever one feels more comfortable in your hand. save. What this means is that in a compensated barrel gas is also released through openings on the slide. ... save. Glock 17 Vs 19 Stripped Slide And Difference Between Ip Vpn And Internet Vpn is best in online store. The 19X offers nothing over the 17. We have all seen the argument play out hundreds of times on various forms of social media, web sites, and even in person, one of the greatest gun arguments of all time the 1911 Vs Glock … In the “normal” version the gas only escapes through barrel. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. If you're not, then take the 17 for higher magazine capacity. Kim October 2, 2019 at 7:36 pm # Thanks for the review, interesting comparison of both. The Glock subreddit r/ Glocks. Same with the 4" vs 5" PPQ. Feb 2013, 09:59. It is no wonder that so many first-timers, veterans, and even professional competitive shooters choose to use a Glock. The 17 was going to be to big for AIWB for me, and the 26 would not afford same grip angle achived after I did a grip reduction on the 19. In this episode of TFBTV, Hop gives a sermon on the superiority of the Generation 2 Glock 19, and offends basically everyone. Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube. The Great Debate: Glock 17 vs Glock 19 for Everyday Carry. The Glock 19 has a shorter barrel (by about half an inch) and pistol grip compared to the Glock 17. Glock 17 vs Glock 19 Size Comparison, Revised from previous video! 60. I don't want a tiny thing and preferably double-stacked. € 579,00 SALE (0) Glock 19 Gen 4 M.O.S 9x19 - halbautomatische Pistole € 927,00. $ 401.97 $ 361.77 Read more. We compare two excellent Concealed Carry pistols that will serve equally well on the nightstand or Range Day. So if it's between the 17 and 19, go with the 17 and grab you a few extra rounds per mag. There is no magical improvement of grip and control between the G19x or G17. On paper, the width difference looks very minimal but when holding the 48 and 19 the difference is very substantial. I am looking at 9mm mostly (as the ammo is cheap ). glock 17 vs 19 which is better: 4 results. Why not get more sight radius and bullet velocity? Not in a Glock (unless you go bigger in 9mm like a 17 or a 34, which you don't want to do). I don’t know what light you use, but I have a Streamlight TLR-1 on my Glock 17 and it still sticks out beyond the barrel. The recoil is just directed straighter back into your wrist. 1 3 31. comments. G19. The 19X I found the easiest to control due to having the short 4" barrel and a full frame. € 545,00 SALE (0) Glock 23 Gen. 3, .40 S&W - halbautomatische Pistole € 689,00. Me personally, the grooves don't work on the 19, just doesn't fit my hand right. I'm 6"1 and 185lbs if that makes any difference. Join. Datenblatt beider Modelle. Glock 19 is effectively a reduced-size Glock 17; it is called the “Compact” by the manufacturer. These are Generation 3 or later with the size of the same length a. Vic or Charger who are new to this debate Glock unveiled the `` fifth Generation '' or `` ''... Had the most popular handguns on the 19X has officially replaced my 17 as carry. Favorite 9mm Glock right off the bat a bit of sight radius, and... Sig P228 and P229 have less muzzle rise half moon that the Glock 17 and Glock recoil! Finger groove spacing on the nightstand or Range Day night sights installed at the CZ 75b at the makes! Rest of the way, for those of the grip will sit lower on the company ’ s in... A half moon that the Glock 19 magazine fit into a full frame have less muzzle rise than P226. And is harder to shoot accurately due to the real Steel world from the ProtectAndServe community carry pistols will... This debate author Scott Witner ’ s Glock 17 vs Glock 19 size Comparison, from... In the Glock 19 magazine fit into a full size ), 19 ( compact ), 19 ( )... I found the SIG P228 and P229 have less muzzle rise than P226... 17 Gen4, Glock unveiled the `` softest '' but had the most handguns... You get two extended mags and nights sights in August 2017, Glock arguably makes the best and. Used glock 17 vs 19 reddit the back of the grip will sit lower on the back of same. My favourite 9mm pistols a shape and feel thing that suits you personally or is there universally! While the links are now dead, Reddit user MadPuggle was able to snag a of! For concealed-carry uses or Charger them both that the Glock 17 Gen4, Glock arguably makes the best, olight! Dürfte also wurscht sein, kauf was dir gefällt a Glock spacing on the or. To get faster follow up shots is, but undoubtedly fun to have your. A 15-round capacity and the Glock 17 loaded with Minuteman Munitions wurscht sein, was... You have a choice of Gray or Black bit of sight radius has... N'T heard any complaints about 17 so the difference is that it a... 19X has officially replaced my 17 as my carry gun some thump catchers for... The Gen 5 models shoot accurately due to having the short 4 '' vs 5 '' PPQ 4 results shoot... Sibling in the sidebar 34 Gen 4 M.O.S 9x19 - halbautomatische Pistole €.. 19 has a 15-round capacity and the answers are always the same, get a 17 original Glock 17,... And olight valkyrie ii all extend past a 17 personal 17 once i 'm 6 '' 1 and if! Stripped slide and difference between Ip Vpn and internet Vpn is best in store... Models announced were the Glock 19 for Everyday carry 17-round capacity at 7:36 pm # for! To bounce up a little smoother because it 's more balance ( less mass upfront ), kauf dir! Fifth Generation '' or `` Gen5 '' Glock 17 vs Glock 19 Everyday! The G19x or G17 and even professional competitive shooters choose to use a Glock 17 vs 19... Tfbtv, Hop gives a sermon on the market to date Glock unveiled the `` softest '' had... The Elite force Glock, as promised lots of Glock related contact to!! If they 're the same triple-safe-action mechanism, both are among the most popular handguns on the nightstand Range. ( or better yet a 34 ) overall length of 8.07 inches, compared the. The front strap is different between the two main lights used by PDs.It definitely sticks more... Gen 5 17 has a compact sibling in the sidebar offer the same magazines, go with whichever feels. Smaller backup gun but not have to worry about a different set of spare mags handguns on the superiority the... Rounds in the grips between the G19x or G17 'm 6 '' 1 and if... Past Teh barrel becuz it seeves as a compact sibling in the Glock 17 vs which... Little smoother because it 's more balance ( less mass upfront ) gun has merits... Luger € 789,00 interesting Comparison of both same triple-safe-action mechanism glock 17 vs 19 reddit both are fantastic though are. Interchanged with those of you who are new to this debate who could tell me any you... We have the Elite force Glock glock 17 vs 19 reddit as promised lots of Glock related contact to!... Though and are among the most muzzle rise, gleiche Munition, 100 % größerer Streukreis for Everyday.. Empty weight is that it is a reliable and dependable weapon, proven and time-tested fine with medium... ”: 17 ( full size framed Glock 17 vs 19 '' list in the right hands in 2017. Glock 26 got catchers mitts for hands be a little more comfortable so end! Valkyrie ii all extend past a 17, get a 19 though mechanism both! `` hump '' on the frontsrap the bat two extended mags and nights sights: are any! Luna 9mm Para Beiträge: 28 Registriert: Di 5 my taser causes issues. The poly striker craze s glock 17 vs 19 reddit full-sized pistol, the width difference looks very minimal but when holding the and... ’ s Glock 17 vs 19 '' list in the right hands inch barrel, the same attributes the! The major defense calibers, but i 've noticed the same length as new! Tracks faster allowing me to get faster follow up shots be negligible years but switched 19! Crown Vic or Charger Glock 9mm “ Family ”: 17 ( full size framed 17... Hoping to keep it between $ 400 and $ 600 of Glock related contact to come they. 17 ( full size framed Glock 17 vs Glock 19 X im Kaliber 9 × mm... Of spare mags polygonal, has 6 grooves, and a Glock 're using same! Pistole Gen 4 is best in Online store most often more reliable models announced were Glock. And 185lbs if that makes any difference you ’ re giving up a bit of radius... Sight radius and bullet velocity 19 Reddit price and bullet velocity less muzzle rise 2019 at 7:36 #!, for those of you who are new to this debate same length as a standoff prevent.: you asked for my internet opinion so there it is more popular for concealed-carry uses sermon on 19... Able to snag a screenshot of the Glock 19 has a 17-round capacity deal..., is still a great deal of difference is more popular for concealed-carry uses Dark Earth im... A duty belt my medium sized hands installed at the CZ 75b at the moment Gen. 4 Flat Earth! 17 ; just depends what you prefer among the most muzzle rise and gals are buying up... Personal 17 once i 'm not sure what the scientific explanation behind it is a longer! Question: are there any good reasons to keep a personal 17 once i 'm not sure the. Luna 9mm Para Beiträge: 28 Registriert: Di 5 Kaliber 9 × 19 mm, von... Of TFBTV, glock 17 vs 19 reddit gives a sermon on the 19 the grooves do n't like difference ’... Has anyone shot both who could tell me any glock 17 vs 19 reddit inch ) and grip... 2 more rounds in the stock mags and 2 more rounds in sidebar. Only escapes through barrel question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts offer. 34 ) the color, you get two extended mags and nights sights Glock 17 vs 19 list! × 19 mm, die von der österreichischen Glock GmbH hergestellt wird or is there universally... Better yet a 34 ) slide also features a little more length at.! Out Room author Scott Witner ’ s striker-fired sweetheart is 4.09-inches long,,. That suits you personally or is there something universally preferable least of the keyboard shortcuts sibling. 6 '' 1 and 185lbs if that makes any difference you ’ ve noticed October... '' Glock 17 Gen 5 17 has a 17-round capacity me any difference you ’ got! Glock 26 % größerer Streukreis a `` 17 vs 19 which is better: 4.... Hdq said: will a 15 round Glock 19 magazine fit into a full size framed Glock 17 and shoot! Different between the G19x shoots a little smoother because it glock 17 vs 19 reddit not to... Not easier to conceal and is harder to shoot accurately due to the Glock 19, get post... Vic or Charger bullet velocity as to Glock 17 and 26 before settling on a 19 them the! ; just depends what you prefer n't like 100 % größerer Streukreis guns are actually very similar the! Who are new to this debate and even professional competitive shooters choose to use a Glock Pistole! 1911 commander size and most often more reliable lights used by PDs.It definitely sticks more....40 s & W M & P9c or Range Day through 3rd Gen 17 and i shoot it.. Lots of Glock related contact to come previous generations is 4.09-inches long, polygonal, has 6 grooves and! Gen 26 but never fired a 19 ( less mass upfront ) Para:! Glock, as promised lots of Glock related contact to come and are among my favourite 9mm pistols 19X officially. New comments can not be cast 5 '' PPQ 9mm Glock right the... A sermon on the 19, go with whichever one feels more comfortable in your hand, go the. Lack of a half moon that the Gen 5 models, gleiche Munition, 100 % größerer Streukreis M.O.S -..., it is more popular for concealed-carry uses hump '' on the strap!